gered/clojure-template-benchmarks
Archived
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull requests Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

added clj-mustache, new results

Browse source
This commit is contained in:
Chris Allen 2013-07-19 13:57:04 -07:00
parent 58a0d9c6b4
commit b0069ac372
3 changed files with 69 additions and 52 deletions
Show stats Download patch file Download diff file Expand all files Collapse all files

82
README.md
View file

@ -6,7 +6,7 @@ Test results are avg / standard deviation.
## Data
Units are in microseconds (us)
The unit 'us' is microseconds. Typical bullshit "ran this on my macbook" arrangement. Run it on your own thing if you care.
<table>
@ -19,91 +19,91 @@ Units are in microseconds (us)
<tr>
<td>str</td>
<td>0.165 us / 0.016 us</td>
<td>14 us / 0.253 us</td>
<td>273 us / 14 us</td>
<td>0.365 us / 0.002 us</td>
<td>29 us / 0.220 us</td>
<td>572 us / 2 us</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>hiccup</td>
<td>20 us / 0.367 us</td>
<td>1100 us / 59 us</td>
<td>24,000 us / 2900 us</td>
<td>0.673 us / 0.006 us</td>
<td>35 us / 1 us</td>
<td>682 us / 3 us</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>hiccup (type-hinted)</td>
<td>0.335 us / 0.013 us</td>
Identical to or slower than non-type-hinted hiccup.
<!-- <td>0.335 us / 0.013 us</td>
<td>25 us / 0.431 us</td>
<td>498 us / 6.2 us</td>
<td>498 us / 6.2 us</td> -->
</tr>
<tr>
<td>clabango (string)</td>
<td>329 us / 5.7 us</td>
<td>1800 us / 146 us</td>
<td>20,600 us / 799 us</td>
<td>544 us / 6.7 us</td>
<td>2452 us / 17 us</td>
<td>30,000 us / 193 us</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>clabango (files)</td>
<td>478 us / 42 us</td>
<td>1,790 us / 52 us</td>
<td>19,900 us / 573 us</td>
<td>665 us / 8.7 us</td>
<td>2,617 us / 22 us</td>
<td>30,450 us / 390 us</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>stencil (string)</td>
<td>58 us / 6 us</td>
<td>212 us / 27 us</td>
<td>930 us / 37 us</td>
<td>90 us / 0.5 us</td>
<td>290 us / 2.7 us</td>
<td>1,300 us / 13 us</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>stencil (file)</td>
<td>1.2 us / 0.022 us</td>
<td>38 us / 0.943 us</td>
<td>784 us / 16 us</td>
<td>2.2 us / 0.019 us</td>
<td>58 us / 0.465 us</td>
<td>1,148 us / 10 us</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>mustache.clj (file)</td>
<td>0.947 us / 0.006 us</td>
<td>26 us / 0.206 us</td>
<td>541 us / 4.7 us</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>tinsel</td>
<td>23.7 us / 5.5 us</td>
<td>1,100 us / 52 us</td>
<td>22,000 us / 770 us</td>
<td>0.678 us / 0.006 us</td>
<td>34 us / 0.175 us</td>
<td>679 us / 7.1 us</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>laser</td>
<td>73.6 us / 1.5 us</td>
<td>243 us / 18 us</td>
<td>3,400 us / 61 us</td>
<td>404 us / 9.4 us</td>
<td>3,770 us / 26 us</td>
<td>68,000 us / 925 us</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>laser (type-hinted)</td>
<td>73.2 us / 3.0 us</td>
<td>220 us / 21 us</td>
<td>3,090 us / 101 us</td>
<td>401 us / 3.1 us</td>
<td>3,764 us / 18 us</td>
<td>69,408 us / 1,028 us</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>enlive</td>
<td>38 us / 0.435 us</td>
<td>320 us / 10 us</td>
<td>6,400 us / 450 us</td>
<td>47 us / 0.397 us</td>
<td>385 us / 8.5 us</td>
<td>6,800 us / 51 us</td>
</tr>
</table>
## Conclusions
+ str is really fast and a huge waste of programmer time.
+ clabango from filesystem templates or string literals are equivalent
+ clabango and hiccup are equivalent in performance
+ stencil from string literals is faster than clabango and hiccup,
+ stencil from files is even faster by a marginal amount.
+ Enlive and Laser are faster than Hiccup and Clabango
+ Hiccup benefits greatly from type-hinting and comes close to str
Copyright © 2013 bitemyapp

16
project.clj
View file

@ -4,12 +4,12 @@
:license {:name "Eclipse Public License"
:url "http://www.eclipse.org/legal/epl-v10.html"}
:main clojure-template-benchmarks.core
:dependencies [[org.clojure/clojure "1.4.0"]
[clabango "0.4"]
[criterium "0.3.1"]
[enlive "1.0.0"]
[hiccup "1.0.2"]
[stencil "0.3.0"]
:dependencies [[org.clojure/clojure "1.5.1"]
[clabango "0.5"]
[criterium "0.4.1"] ; 0.3.1
[enlive "1.1.1"]
[hiccup "1.0.3"]
[stencil "0.3.2"]
[tinsel "0.4.0" :exclusions [hickory]]
[me.raynes/laser "0.1.21"]
[enlive "1.0.1"]])
[me.raynes/laser "1.1.1"]
[me.shenfeng/mustache "1.1"]])

23
src/clojure_template_benchmarks/core.clj
View file

@ -5,7 +5,8 @@
[stencil.core :as stencil]
[hiccup.core :as hiccup]
[me.raynes.laser :as laser :refer [defdocument]]
[net.cgrand.enlive-html :as enlive]))
[net.cgrand.enlive-html :as enlive]
[me.shenfeng.mustache :as mustache]))
(def bar (str "bar"))
@ -64,6 +65,14 @@
(defn list-stencil [ceil]
(stencil/render-file "clojure_template_benchmarks/templates/list.mustache" {:items (range 1 ceil)}))
(mustache/deftemplate simple-mst (slurp "src/clojure_template_benchmarks/templates/simple.mustache"))
(mustache/deftemplate list-mst (slurp "src/clojure_template_benchmarks/templates/list.mustache"))
(defn simple-mustache []
(simple-mst {:bar bar}))
(defn list-mustache [ceil]
(list-mst {:items (range 1 ceil)}))
(deftemplate simple-tinsel [[:span {:class "foo"}]] [] (has-class? "foo") (set-content bar))
(deftemplate list-tinsel [[:ul]] [ceil] (tag= :ul) (set-content (for [x (range 1 ceil)] [:li x])))
@ -71,14 +80,14 @@
(defdocument simple-laser "<span class=\"foo\"></span>" []
(laser/class= "foo") (laser/content bar))
(defdocument list-laser "<ul></ul>" [ceil]
(laser/element= :ul) (laser/html-content
(laser/element= :ul) (laser/content
(for [x (range 1 ceil)]
(laser/node :li :content (str x)))))
(defdocument simple-laser-hinted "<span class=\"foo\"></span>" []
(laser/class= "foo") (laser/content ^String bar))
(defdocument list-laser-hinted "<ul></ul>" [ceil]
(laser/element= :ul) (laser/html-content
(laser/element= :ul) (laser/content
(for [x (range 1 ceil)]
(laser/node :li :content (str ^Number x)))))
@ -153,6 +162,14 @@
(with-progress-reporting (quick-bench (list-stencil 1000)))
(println "\n --- \n")
(println "\n\n ***** mustache file ***** \n\n")
(with-progress-reporting (quick-bench (simple-mustache)))
(println "\n --- \n")
(with-progress-reporting (quick-bench (list-mustache 50)))
(println "\n --- \n")
(with-progress-reporting (quick-bench (list-mustache 1000)))
(println "\n --- \n")
(println "\n\n ***** tinsel ***** \n\n")
(with-progress-reporting (quick-bench (simple-tinsel)))
(println "\n --- \n")